Blog Style or Sort By Most Bumps This... Day  Week  Month  Life
Long-Time GameSpot Editor Fired. Negative Review To Blame?Posted 8:04pm Thu Nov 29, 2007 by Aaron Dunlap Tags: Jeff Gerstmann, GameSpot, EIDOS, firing, politics, Kane and Lynch
6

We have it on good authority from a source close to GameSpot that Jeff Gerstmann, a GameSpot employee for over 10 years and more recently titled as an editorial director was abruptly fired yesterday.

While there is no official reason for this, many people (our source included) and convinced that he was fired because of a somewhat negative review of EIDOS's Kane & Lynch: Dead men. EIDOS had been advertising pretty heavily on GameSpot recently, and apparently the 6.0 didn't please them.

We received the following statement from the Human Relations department of C|NET after inquiry.

"... it is CNET Networks company policy to never comment on individual employees current or former regarding their job status. This policy is in place out of respect for the individuals privacy."

Interestingly, the online gaming-themed comic Penny Arcade has just published this strip, featuring the firing of Gerstmann. How they knew about it is anybody's guess at this point, as no news story has been posted for it yet. Keep in mind that there is no official confirmation from any parties about the firing.

Today there was no episode of On The Spot, a video segment that Gerstmann typically hosts.

GameSpot's 6/10 review of the game, while low, isn't unique. GamePro and GameSpy also gave the game 60% scores, with no high-profile outlets giving any scores above a 90%.
 Share:
Related Stories

Idea: Maybe GameSpot Needs A Writers Strike [11/30/07] 100% match
Gerstmann Firing Not GameSpot's Fault, Say... [11/30/07] 100% match
GameSpot (Finally) Responds to 'GerstmannG... [12/06/07] 67% match
Gerstmann's K&L Review Was Heavily 'Toned... [12/05/07] 67% match
Eidos Reduces K&L Fake Rating Complaints t... [12/04/07] 50% match
Official Kane & Lynch Website Lies About I... [12/02/07] 50% match
GameSpot (Finally) Issues a Statement Rega... [12/03/07] 33% match
shiva
Sad.
Reply | Posted: 12:59am Fri Nov 30, 2007

Avid
That's rough.
Reply | Posted: 1:15am Fri Nov 30, 2007

TimGrube
He was a good guy. Met him several times at industry events. I never had daily contact with him, but only a few times a year. He knows his shit though. He won't have a hard time looking for a job.
Reply | Posted: 9:04am Fri Nov 30, 2007

Please Log In

Please log in or register if you want to leave a comment.

Username
Password
Tag Search
Features
Reviews
Previews
Videos
Screenshots
Game Demos
GamingHorizon Archive
Current Events
e3Feed Work For Us
Most Used Tags
Xbox 360 (249)
PlayStation 3 (235)
PC (126)
PSP (120)
Wii (118)
Sony (115)
PlayStation 2 (113)
Nintendo (86)
Screens (80)
Editorial (74)
Nintendo DS (61)
Microsoft (60)
E3 2008 (51)
Update (39)
Rumor (37)
Xbox (37)
Virtual Console (36)
People (32)
Activision (28)
E3 (26)
Ubisoft (26)
Playstation Store (25)
Square Enix (24)
EA (23)
Xbox Live (21)
Halo 3 (21)
Nintendo Wii (19)
GameBump (19)
Xbox Live Arcade (19)
Capcom (19)
Assassins Creed (19)
Politics (16)
Sega (15)
Konami (15)
World Of Warcraft (14)
Call Of Duty 4 (14)
Electronic Arts (14)
Valve (14)
Japan (14)
Eidos (14)
Namco Bandai (13)
Scores (13)
Devil May Cry 4 (12)
Rock Band (12)
Sales (12)
DS (12)
Atlus (12)
Blizzard (12)
Gallery (11)
Rockstar (11)